Ha, I was going to write to you about this. I discovered it last week while I was shopping for a generic substitute. The store had the migraine type in caplets only and I really wanted tablets, so I decided to check the ingredients. Imagine my surprise when I noticed they were the same thing--except the migraine medicine had a $1 higher price tag! So to answer ICC and Glen, no, the prices are not the same. The "specialized" version was markedly more expensive. I'm not sure if the Excedrin itself is the same price or not, but I do know the generics are different.