Actually, I agree with the judge 100%. To me, weight "management" implies the ability to keep my current weight "under control", not "loss" or "gain". In fact, that term would have raised my "radar" immediately because it would have struck me that they were consciously avoiding any commitment to being able to achieve the goal of weight loss. "Appetite control" would have told me that it might help curb my hunger/cravings, but that in itself is not a sure indicator that weight loss will occur. If anything, "appetite control" would make me hope that I could *avoid* a weight gain, but all in all, the only road to weight loss is less calories in and more calories out.