I agree with Pierre here. White chocolate is not even really chocolate in the first place so arguing that there's no chocolate in them is ridiculous. However arguing that the ingredients that commonly go into white chocolate aren't there isn't ridiculous, but when you dissect the ingredient list it's still arguable as to whether there are enough of them to pass, especially if they put the word "natural flavor" in there to qualify it. So I get why the case was thrown out. The only thing they should do is make that little phrase "natural flavor" bigger. And besides, Clif bars are really good!!