Updated every Monday!   Subscribe to free weekly newsletter.

April 9, 2018

A Macy’s Rebate Gone Wrong

Filed under: Internet,Retail — Edgar (aka MrConsumer) @ 6:00 am

SensorGel pillowRight after Christmas, Consumer World promoted a deal on a SensorGel pillow at Macy’s as “Bargain of the Week.” It was $20, but there was a $20 full price rebate.

In January, MrConsumer’s own rebate submission was denied by the rebate fulfillment house indicating that no receipt was received. Of course I had included it. Calling them quickly revealed that indeed they had my receipt in their records, and the rebate was approved.

Then in February, some consumers contacted me saying that their rebate was denied because they purchased the pillow online rather than in the store. Here is what one consumer was told when he engaged the rebate folks in a chat session:

Macy's rebate denial

After complaints like this starting coming in, we checked the fine print of the offer on the rebate form.


Macy's rebate fine print

Clearly, right on the rebate form itself, both online and in-store purchases were permitted for this rebate.

Since it appeared that many purchasers may have had their rebates wrongfully denied, we contacted Macy’s PR folks, asking them to investigate, and if they discovered that customers were indeed owed money, that they honor those submissions. After multiple contacts, Macy’s did not reply to our inquiries.

So, MrConsumer had to use some back-channel methods to get Macy’s to do the right thing. He contacted the former CEO of Parago, the rebate fulfillment house that Macy’s uses, to ask her help. This remarkable woman dropped everything eight years ago to address a similar problem with a Norton rebate. She did the same again by contacting the new CEO at Blackhawk Network, the new owner of the fulfillment house.

A week later, a representative of Blackhawk called to say that after discussion with Macy’s and a review of all the denied rebates, they are making good for some 150 customers! And they are also going to more accurately state on the rebate form when an offer is restricted to in-store or online sales only.

Share this story:


• • •


  1. A rhetorical question: Can Macy’s ever get anything right? Their merchandise is way overpriced. They constantly run bogus sales. Their customer service is abysmal. Their stores are messy.

    Comment by HMC — April 9, 2018 @ 7:09 am
  2. Great work! It’s always comforting to know that someone is supporting consumers

    Comment by Wayne — April 9, 2018 @ 12:41 pm
  3. So what was their excuse for not fulfilling their OWN RULES when it was FIRST pointed out to them rather than waiting til the Atom Bomb was dropped on them? Saying you’ll do better in future tells me you’ll just try harder not to get caught. Doesn’t sound like they’re owning up to refusing to do what’s right at all. Big surprise, huh?

    Comment by teri clark — April 9, 2018 @ 2:33 pm
  4. Well done Edgar!!!

    Comment by george stasinopoulos — April 9, 2018 @ 9:52 pm

Comments RSS

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by: WordPressPrivacy Policy
Mouse Print exposes the strings and catches buried in the fine print of advertising.
Copyright © 2006-2019. All rights reserved. Advertisements are copyrighted by their respective owners.